Skip to content


Dozens Dead When Illegal Building Collapses in Mumbai

Comments Off

Death Toll Expected to Rise

AT LEAST 45 PEOPLE HAVE DIED and more than 50 others were injured Thursday evening in Mumbai (Bombay), India, when a partially-occupied building collapsed around them.

The Hindu

The combination apartment and commercial structure had four stories completed and mostly occupied while work continued to raise it to eight stories.  The construction crews were working on the eighth floor when it all suddenly gave way.

The building was being constructed illegally without any permits or oversight.  It is also suspected that the builder was using sub-standard materials and techniques in order to save time and money on the job.

FoxNews is reporting:

Rescue workers with sledgehammers, gasoline-powered saws and hydraulic jacks struggled Friday to break through the tower of rubble in their search for possible survivors. Six bulldozers were brought to the scene.

"There may be (a) possibility people have been trapped inside right now," local police commissioner K.P. Raghuvanshi said Friday.

At the time of the collapse, between 100 and 150 people were in the building. Many were residents or construction workers, who were living at the site as they worked on it, said Sandeep Malvi, a spokesman for the (local) government.

More than 20 people remained missing Friday afternoon and three floors of the building remained to be searched, said R.S. Rajesh, an official with the National Disaster Response Force who was at the scene.

Building collapses are common in India as builders try to cut corners by using poor quality materials, and multi-storied structures are built with inadequate supervision. The massive demand for housing around India's cities and pervasive corruption allow builders to add unauthorized floors or build entirely illegal buildings.

The neighborhood where the building collapsed was part of a belt of more than 2,000 illegal structures that had sprung up in the area in recent years, said Malvi, the town spokesman.

 

BBC News tells us that witnesses say the construction of the building started just six weeks ago and in that time, seven floors were built rapidly and the eighth floor was under construction.  Even though the construction was incomplete, the builder had allowed families to move in.

The Hindu is also reporting:

Alok Awasthi, Commandant of the National Disaster Response Force (NDRF), which has been pressed into service to assist the local police and civic administration in rescue efforts, said 59 people had been pulled out alive but some more survivors could still be trapped under the debris.

Cranes were being used to remove the rubble, floor-by-floor, to trace the survivors with the help of life detector sensors which could pick up signals from possible survivors from 70 metre deep, he said.

State-of-the-art equipment fitted with thermal cameras were being inserted into the wreckage after making holes to locate survivors and extricate them with gas cutters, Awasthi said.

"The presence of large number of people and noise are hampering rescue efforts as it is difficult for the sensors to pick up signals of existing life under such a huge wreckage," said the NDRF Commandant, whose team of 90 men is working round-the-clock, at the scene of the incident.

For more details read the entire story in The Hindu HERE.

The police have registered a case of culpable homicide against the builder and the two owners. All of them have absconded and are being searched for.

This video report from NDTV does a good job of explaining the illegalities and corruptions associated with this building:

 

*  *  *  *  *  *  *

Partial-Building Collapse Without Warning

Comments Off

In the Middle of the Night

THE TOP TWO FLOORS OF AN 8-STORY office building in Shanghai, China, collapsed suddenly on Sunday morning.  Fortunately it was in the middle of the night and no people are believed to have been in or around the building at the moment.

Shanghaiist

Dozens of police cars, fire engines and ambulances staged at the intersection while police, fire and other departments had entered the building surveying and searching for any trapped people.

Shanghaiist

The city officials are still puzzled over what caused the partial collapse without any previous warning that it was unstable.  One of the local residents told China News:  "This building is several decades old, how can it suddenly just fall down one night? It was lucky that it didn't fall on anyone."  The city engineers are considering the possibility that a remodelng project on the upper floors may have taken out a load-bearing wall.

The Shanghaiist posted this video report taped shortly after the event (it is a collection of clips, so let the video run for the full two minutes):

 

*  *  *

China News

*  *  *  *  *  *  *

4-Alarm Warehouse Fire in Chicago

Comments Off

3-Story Brick Stucture Fully Involved

A 3-STORY BRICK FACTORY / WAREHOUSE in Chicago, Illinois, burned out and partially collapsed Saturday afternoon.  The building was occupied, but it has not yet been disclosed what sort of business was using it or what was inside that was burning. 

ChicagoAreaFire / Haak

The Chicago Tribune is reporting:

The blaze was reported in a 100-by-300 foot, 2-story warehouse at 2444 W. 21st St. about 1:12 p.m., and as of 1:20 p.m. evacuations were underway, according to Fire Media. The 3-11 alarm was called at 1:40 p.m., and the 4-11 alarm followed soon after. The 4-11 alarm was struck out at about 3:47 p.m.

At about 2:43 p.m., Fire Media reported the building was starting to collapse.

Heavy smoke was seen coming from the building as firefighters arrived, and fire was reported throughout the structure, according to Fire Media. All companies were working, with 11 master streams on the fire, and firefighters experienced exposure problems.

ChicagoAreaFire tells us:

First units found a three-story, brick, commercial factory/warehouse well involved. The alarms quickly escalated to a 4-11 with an EMS Plan I and a Haz Mat Level I. The building was bounded on the west by railroad tracks and on the north by the elevated CTA tracks which were shut down for several hours. The EMS Plan was secured quickly and the 4-11 wasn’t struck out until roughly 4PM. Some companies remained on the scene throughout the night.

Two Snorkels (Squad 1 and the reserve Snorkel) were working along with four tower ladders (5, 10, 39 & 54).

ChicagoAreaFire / Haak

Dave Weaver, Radioman911 also reports from his radio transcriptions:

13:08 E23 looking for rubbish 2500 W. Cullerton St. / Full Still b/o Main FAO for 2444 W. 21st St.

13:13 Still & Box Alarm b/o Batt 4 for 3 story 200×100 smoke on 2nd fl and heavy smoke from several 1st fl windows »

13:20 2-11 Alarm b/o 2-2-1 reports heavy fire throughout 3 story warehouse 200×150 » Companies go defensive » Batt 2 requests CTA Pink Line be shut down »

13:31 2-2-1 requests additional TL and reserve snorkel » Corrected size-up by 2-2-1 is at least 300×150 » 13:38 3-11 Alarm b/o 2-1-28 plus 2 additional TLs »

13:45 4-11 Alarm / EMS Plan 1 / Level 1 HazMat b/o 2-1-28 » 13:58 2-7-1/Batt 4 4 master streams on West side of building making little progress » 14:00 EMS Plan 1 secured b/o 2-1-28 » 14:04 2-1-3 in command / All officers switch to Ch 5 Command » 14:30 2-7-1/2-1-3 11 master streams working, gas company digging in Sector 1 to shut off main, 1 line to sprinkler system in Sector 4.

 

For Full Radio Traffic from Radioman911.com click the following links:

Part 1 www.justin.tv/radioman911/b/352277818
Part 2 www.justin.tv/radioman911/b/352275440

Part 3 www.justin.tv/radioman911/b/352272510

CLICK HERE and HERE to view ChicagoAreaFire's extensive and exemplary photo gallery plus video coverage.

*  *  *  *  *  *  *

2 Dead, 18 Injured as Firefighters Save 56 More in Partial Building Collapse in Ukraine

Comments Off

One of Those Places With No Safety Codes

A SECTION OF A 5-STORY APARTMENT BUILDING suddenly collapsed early Sunday morning in Lutsk, Ukraine.

All photos via Volynska Gazeta

The section that fell away destroyed 8 apartments in the block-long building but fortunately only the outer rooms of the affected units were involved and most of the residents were able to survive.  At least two bodies have been found so far and one woman was severely injured.  Most of the residents were able to flee to the opposite side of the building where they were rescued by firefighters using ladders to the windows and balconies.  Of the 50+ victims taken down, 18 of them were injured and and treated on the scene with two more taken to hospitals for treatment.

About 90 firefighters and 21 pieces of apparatus responded to the call at 4:25 am.  The fire department's equivalent of a US&R team went quickly to work searching for any victims.

The Associated Press adds:

The cause of the disaster was not immediately known, but Ukraine's Channel 5 TV said authorities suspect unauthorized repair work being done in the building's basement.

Buildings frequently collapse in Ukraine, where infrastructure is outdated and safety rules are often neglected.

The building was constructed in 1971.

The Volnyska Gazeta has the story and more photos HERE.

This raw video documents the retrieval of one of the victims:

 

*  *  *  *  *  *  *

Building Collapse Kills 5, Injures 5 More

Comments Off

Buried In Basement

A 2-STORY BUILDING IN BARLETTA, ITALY, COLLAPSED during the noon hour Wednesday with ten people inside.  Most of the occupants were women working in a small knitting mill in the basement of the building.  Also inside were the owners of the property and their 14-yr.-old daughter.

all photos La Repubblica

Everybody was trapped inside the collapsed building and five of them perished under the rubble.  The Vigili del Fuoco (fire department) responded promptly along with other rescue and search teams and began pulling off the debris aided by dozens of civilians and construction workers from nearby.

The first to be extricated was the young girl who was killed.  The final two victims to be removed were both alive when they were found and rescued ten hours later.

The cause for the sudden collapse is initially thought to be from some work being done to shore up an adjacent building that was deemed unsafe.  The structure on the other side had already collapsed about a year ago.  There is much local anger against the city council for allowing the situation to continue that led to Wednesday's collapse.

La Repubblica has the detailed story HERE.
Extensive photo galleries HERE, HERE, and HERE.

*  *  *  *  *  *  *

Three Dead in Paris Building Collapse

Comments Off

Condemned Building Undergoing Renovation

A MOTHER AND HER TWO CHILDREN died early this morning when a vacant hotel collapsed onto their apartment building.

Liberation photo

The 4-story hotel has been vacant for years and was recently condemned by the local council.  According to neighbors, renovation work had begun on it several months ago and it is believed that the interior had been gutted. Just before midnight "everything fell in a thud" one neighbor stated.  Practically the entire hotel fell against the four-unit apartment house that was home to 16 people.

When the building came down, part of the debris crashed onto the hood of passing police car, so the alarm went out immediately.  Eventually there were 120 firefighters from 20 companies on the scene along with rescue dogs to search for any more survivors or victims in the two buildings.  The search process lasted for 11 hours until the entire rubble had been looked through.  Several dozen people in other buildings were evacuated until their buildings had been declared safe to return.

AFP

Besides the woman and two children (one of them an infant) who died, 8 other people were injured, 3 adults and 5 children.

The investigation has already started into the cause and a police forensic team is on the site, too.  The vacant building's owner has been taken into police custody while the investigation takes place.

Liberation has the story HERE and HERE.

This video report carries views of the collapse site:

 

*  *  *  *  *  *  *

Do You Really Want a Flat Roof?

1 comment

Why Do They Continue To Put Flat Roofs on Large Buildings?

FIREGEEZER HAS NEVER UNDERSTOOD WHY architects continue to design building with flat roofs.  Even without any weather disasters they ALWAYS leak rainwater eventually,  no matter what kind of roofing material is used.  And when you get the occasional winter with back-to-back snowstorms, well ……….

 

 

Industrial Building Collapses With 30 Workers Inside – All Alive

Comments Off

Building Completely Destroyed – Everyone Escapes

AN INDUSTRIAL BUILDING IN MILFORD, CONNECTICUT, collapsed suddenly Wednesday at 11:30 am with approx. 30 employees inside.  All of them were able to self-evacuate after the catastrophic collapse, but two people had to be transported for non-life threatening injuries.

New Haven Register

When the Milford Fire Department arrived on the scene they encounterd a large gas leak from the severance of the service line along with live electrical lines.  The regional USAR team was mobilized and a haz-mat team was brought in due to several dangerous chemicals such as cyanide and sulphuric acid.  It is probable that the business was engaged in metal plating.

A Fire Captain with the Milford Fire Department held this press conference
that is presented here in two parts by the New Haven Register:

 

WTNH-TV Ch. 8 filed this video report with additional views of the destruction:

 

It is conditionally thought that a heavy load of wetted snow on the flat roof of the building caused the collapse.  Search dogs along with the USAR team are giving thorough search through the rubble, but it is strongly believed that everyone has been accounted for.

*  *  *  *  *  *  *

Updated – Store Explosion, People Trapped in Michigan

1 comment

Update:  Store owner rescued, seriously injured.  More video added.  Scroll down.
Update, Thursday am:  Other two people found dead late Wednesday night.  Scroll down.

A DESTRUCTIVE EXPLOSION INSIDE a furniture store in Wayne, Michigan, caused an immediate collapse of the center portion of the building.

WJBK-TV

The blast occurred at 9 am Eastern time and it is believed that anywhere from 2 to 5 people are trapped in the rubble.  The William C. Franks Furniture store is literally destroyed in what the City Manager said to be a natural gas explosion.  The Wayne Fire Department responded to the scene and the area USAR team is working the collapse.  Search dogs have also been called to the location.

Update:  A recent report says that one person has been rescued from the building and has been transported to a burn unit.

WXYZ-TV Ch. 7 Detroit has this early report from the scene:

 

The store occupies slightly more than a half-city block and has been in business for 44 years.

This is still a working incident.  Firegeezer will be updating during the day.

WJBK-TV Ch.2 has a 32- image PHOTO GALLERY HERE.

WJBK-TV images

*  *  *  *  *  *  *

Update, 2:30 pm:
The store’s owner, Paul Franks is the first person to be recovered from the collapsed building.  He was found fairly soon into the operation and was transported to the University of Michigan Trauma Burn Center in Ann Arbor where he is listed in critical condition.  There are two others believed to be trapped inside, a secretary and a salesman.

The Detroit News continues:

Shawn Bell, deputy chief fire marshal for the city of Wayne, said rescuers are inside the partially collapsed store doing a systematic hand-to-hand search for the victims. He would not confirm how many are still believed to be inside.

“There’s a lot of danger of further collapse, so we have to take precautions for the rescuers in there,” Bell said.

He added that crews were using listening devices to detect any sounds from the victims as well as calling cell phones of those believed to have been inside the building at the time of collapse. So far, there has been no response.  Canine search and rescue teams were on the way, he said.

Most of the initial fires were extinguished, but there are still hot spots inside that firefighters are extinguishing, he said.

The Associated Press is relaying that the cars of the two people believed missing are parked next to the store.  Some other employees are on the scene assisting rescuers by indicating areas where they were most likely to be at the time of the explosion.

“We’re pretty sure natural gas is involved,” Consumers Energy spokeswoman Debra Dodd said. The utility received a call of a possible gas leak in the area several hours before the blast and a worker had been trying to track down the source when the explosion took place, Dodd said. She said the gas main to the building has been shut off and that another line in the area would be closed as a precaution.

 Jennifer Gietzen, 36, who co-manages an auto repair shop with her husband about a block from the furniture store, said the smell of natural gas was “overwhelming.”

Firefighters, police, emergency search crews and the Department of Homeland Security responded to the scene within minutes. They came from Inkster, Garden City, Canton, Farmington Hills, Taylor, Romulus and Dearborn Heights.

Search and rescue teams came from Oakland and Washtenaw counties.

As the day wore on, searchers dug gingerly through the rubble, bringing out piles a little at a time for dogs to sniff. City Manager John Zech said rescue crews had to approach the search carefully, in case of further collapse. Wayne Deputy Chief/Fire Marshal Shawn Bell said rescuers were hoping to find signs of life in crevices and gaps created by debris landing at angles.

“It’s a very slow and tedious process,” Bell said. “A lot of the debris removal is being done by hand.”

Fire Chief Mel Moore said the search had been complicated by the weight of the building’s concrete roof trusses.

“We’re pretty sure natural gas is involved,” Consumers Energy spokeswoman Debra Dodd said.

The utility received a call of a possible gas leak in the area several hours before the blast and a worker had been trying to track down the source when the explosion took place, Dodd said. She said the gas main to the building has been shut off and that another line in the area would be closed as a precaution. 

Jennifer Gietzen, 36, who co-manages an auto repair shop with her husband about a block from the furniture store, said the smell of natural gas was “overwhelming.”

This home video was taken in the area just prior to the first engine’s arrival:

 

This raw video just filed by WSYR-TV has an aerial view of the labor-intensive search that is underway:

 

Update, Thursday 6 am:
The bodies of the two missing employees were both located between 7:30 pm and 10 pm Wednesday night.  First found was the 64-yr.-old salesman and 2-½ hours later the female employee, reported to be the store’s secretary, was located.  Both had perished in the collapse.  The store owner, Paul Franks remains in the University of Michigan hospital in Ann Arbor, however his condition has been upgraded from critical to serious-but-stable.

The Detroit Free Press is reporting this morning:

Firefighters, police, emergency search crews and the Department of Homeland Security responded to the scene within minutes.  They came from Inkster, Garden City, Canton, Farmington Hills, Taylor, Romulus and Dearborn Heights.  Search and rescue teams came from Oakland and Washtenaw counties.

As the day wore on, searchers dug gingerly through the rubble, bringing out piles a little at a time for dogs to sniff.  City Manager John Zech said rescue crews had to approach the search carefully, in case of further collapse.  Wayne Deputy Chief/Fire Marshal Shawn Bell said rescuers were hoping to find signs of life in crevices and gaps created by debris landing at angles.

Free Press / Mitchell

“It’s a very slow and tedious process,” Bell said. “A lot of the debris removal is being done by hand.”  Fire Chief Mel Moore said the search had been complicated by the weight of the building’s concrete roof trusses.

 Consumers Energy, the gas utility that serves the area was first notified of a possible leak in the area around 6:15 a.m. and again an hour and a half later.  The explosion happened during the investigation of the second call.

The Associated Press has filed this summary video report this morning:

 

WJBK-TV Ch. 2 has provided this video report with comments by neighbors affected by the blast:

 

*  *  *  *  *

WJBK-TV / SkyFox image

Konstanz Fire Update

3 comments

THURSDAY WE REPORTED ON A TENACIOUS FIRE in the historic center of Konstanz, Germany, near the Swiss border that destroyed at least one building that was more than 500 years old.  (See the Firegeezer REPORT HERE that includes a dramatic sequence of collapse photos.)  Our friends at FWnetz, the leading fire/rescue news site in Germany, have passed along an update.

The fire is still burning. The THW – a special civil protection unit – is stabilizing neighboring houses because of the risk of collapse.  Therefore the fire brigade is not able to put the fire out.  Officials say the operation will take a couple of days.  20 people lost their home, including a family of 5.  Today it is snowing.  The weather forecast says there will be 20 to 30 centimeters (=up to one foot) of snow this night – not a good (outlook) because of the risk of collapse.

photo by Schutzbach

DPA (German Press Association) is reporting today that the fire may have started from a burning advent wreath on the third floor, and three more homes have been heavily damaged.

Sud Kurier is reporting that when the fire was beginning, a street-cleaning crew spotted an 84-yr.-old man standing in the ground-floor with his hair on fire.  They ran into the building to take him out, saving the shocked man’s life.  He is hospitalized with burn injuries.  Firefighters rescued a 73-yr.-old woman from one of the upper floors by taking her out a window.  She was transported and treated for smoke inhalation.   All the other occupants apparently escaped safely.  The same link to Sud Kurier also takes you to five photo galleries with more than 200 pics.

Fire crews are expected to remain on the scene through Saturday at least.

Parking Deck Collapse in New Jersey

1 comment

Update: The North Jersey regional USAR team has been dispatched to the call.

A 3-STORY PARKING GARAGE IN HACKENSACK, NEW JERSEY, COLLAPSED around 10 am Friday morning.  The structure serves an 18-story apartment building but it is not yet known if or how many victims are trapped underneath the pancaked concrete rubble.

The collapse was caused by a glass and metal cantilevered canopy that covered the entrance way between the garage and the apartment building.  The canopy pulled away from the high-rise and fell on the top of the parking deck, causing a secondary collapse of the below-grade structure.

WABC-TV

Search dogs are on the scene looking for any sign of human occupation of the garage.  The apartment building has been evacuated as a precaution and reports from the scene describe it as a giant sinkhole covered with the fallen canopy with all the cars mashed below it.

WABC-TV provided this early raw video of the scene taken from their helicopter:

The timing was fortunate in that most of the residents had already left for work and few cars were there at the time.

WNBC-TV has more of the STORY HERE.

 

General Alarm in Massachusetts

Comments Off

A MAJOR DOWNTOWN FIRE IN MARLBOROUGH, MASSACHUSETTS, went to 8 alarms Saturday afternoon, located in the heart of city’s commercial district.

Boston Globe / Cooper

The fire began in a 4-story woodframe building housing a restaurant and a hair salon on the ground floor with nine apartments in the 3 floors above.  The fire grew rapidly in the old wooden building presenting an immediate challenge to the FD to contain it.  When the first units arrived shortly  after 12:15 pm, fire  was showing on the 2nd floor, but all of the employees and residents had evacuated safely.  The Boston Globe reported:

Marlborough Fire Chief Rick Plummer said the wooden structure ignited quickly and erupted into a major blaze that threatened to burn the adjacent buildings on Main Street. He said quick work from his department and 14 others from around the area saved a bank and a convenience store in the adjacent buildings.

“If we didn’t stop it when we did, it would have continued to burn down the street,’’ Plummer said. “It was a manpower-intensive fire.’’

Plummer said none of the residents or anyone in the businesses was injured, but three firefighters, one whom was transported to Marlborough Hospital in stable condition, suffered from heat exhaustion.

MetroWest Daily News posted some excellent fire footage on this video report:

Fortunately the exposure buildings are brick construction and aided in containment which was the priority effort.  Extra alarms were called because of the brutal heat and humidity of the day’s weather and crews were rotated for safety.  Just before 3 pm there were signs of imminent collapse and the crews pulled back just before the building fully collapsed into the street.

The fire was largely knocked down by 4:30.  It is not yet known how or where  the fire started, but some residents believe it began in the restaurant’s kitchen.  Investigators will be working today to determine the cause.

The Daily News has MORE.

Daily News / Cieri

Downtown Explosion in Belgium

5 comments

Updated:  scroll down.

A BUILDING IN THE CENTER OF LIEGE, BELGIUM, was ripped by an explosion at 1:45 am local time this morning (Wednesday).  The blast is believed to have been caused by natural gas, but when the FD arrived the interior of the building was demolished with several fires in different locations throughout the 5-story structure.

liege c sudpresse

Sud Presse (Belgium)

Fortunately for the FF’s, the building was untenable and all the fire attack had to be done from the outside.

liege b

Sud Presse

Five hours later while the FF’s were still knocking down the fires from outside, the building suddenly collapsed to the ground.

This news video courtesy of Sky News shows the collapse:

There were about 20 people injured by the collapse with at least two hurt seriously.  Early reports say that two, and perhaps four, people are unaccounted for, but it was not said whether they are firefighters or civilians.

liege a reut

Reuters

Paris Match has the early STORY.
Sud Presse has a 172-image photo gallery HERE.

Update, 5 pm:
A 13-yr.-old girl has been found alive in the rubble as the rescuers continue their extensive search of the building.  The total number injured and hospitalized now stands at 23.  Later in the evening the body of one dead was located and removed.

Update, 10 pm:
More bodies have been retrieved.  See Firegeezer Update posting with more information and additional videos HERE.