Skip to content


No Charges in Boston Ladder Crash

Comments

SUFFOLK DISTRICT ATTORNEY DANIEL CONLEY announced at a press conference Thursday that there will be no criminal charges filed on the accident last January when a Boston FD ladder truck lost its brakes on a hill and crashed into an apartment building.  The wreck claimed the life of Fire Lieutenant Kevin Kelley, a 30-yr. firefighter with the department.

ladder 26 a globe ryan

Boston Globe / Ryan file photo

This incident garnered wide coverage around the fire/ems community and it also led to a new look at how the BFD’s vehicle maintenance program is carried out.  Once that rock was lifted, all kinds of ugly things came running out, including a lack of certification of the truck mechanics, no routine preventive maintenance program, no daily in-station checks, among other things.

In yesteday’s press conference, Conley said that the Boston Fire Department failed to provide adequate training on how to handle firetrucks in emergency situations.  The Boston Globe reports:

The driver did not know to check brake pressure before he got behind the wheel that day and then, when the brakes failed, did not know how to engage secondary braking systems.

Instead, he pumped the brakes, releasing any remaining air pressure from the brake system, and put the truck into neutral, preventing the secondary brakes from engaging.

But the findings underscored the Boston Fire Department’s woeful lack of training, Conley said. Standard industry practices would have dictated that firefighters inspect trucks daily, including air pressure on the brakes, and that they be trained in all aspects of handling trucks.

Conley wrote in his report that (Operator) O’Neill had only “limited classroom instruction and no driver training in the proper use of air brakes in downhill and emergency circumstances.’’

“In point of fact,’’ Conley wrote,’’ Firefighter O’Neill was not aware that his desperate efforts to slow Ladder 26 during its accelerating descent down Parker Hill Avenue could have had the opposite effect.’’

Not only was the training seriously deficient, but the entire maintenance program was exposed as nearly non-existant.  The Globe continues:

The main cause was brake failure, probably the result of years of “insufficient and substandard’’ maintenance, Conley said.

“An examination of the truck found reduced braking power on both front wheels, significantly reduced braking power on the rear right wheel, and nonexistent brakes on the rear left.’’

Read the entire article in this morning’s edition of the Boston Globe HERE.

WCVB-TV Ch. 5 has a video report on yesterday’s press conference along with a summary of the accident:

D

Share and Post on Facebook, Twitter and More:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • email
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • joebideau
    Aluminum and plastic fire trucks, A Seagrave would have knocked the building down......
  • DaGonz
    A Brother died in the line of duty ... and you make a stupid remark?

    I was there at Kevin Kelley's funeral... were you?
  • moe
    It seems from his message all he is interested in is selling fire trucks.... not celebrate the life of brother firefighter who lost his life in a needless accident.

    So sad....

    RIP brother
  • joebideau
    Nothing about funerals, and the remark is the truth. Looking at the photos, I can see that this truck with 110 ft. ladder on a single ax in the rear and lots of truck company equipment is too heavy for a single. I do not know if it has a jake or a Telma, but after reading the skivvy on the service and what is wrong with it, would comment that the Boston FD is a very unsafe place to work. We also heard 26 was replaced with another aluminum fire truck. Riding to a fire in an aluminum cab is like riding in an egg shell. Only a dozen or so men are killed each year in these cheap cabs, so the nfpa committees do not pay any attention. Since 1960 all the custom builders save one are out of business, big money got into this lucrative business, and the four large aluminum giants, and others, are screwing the cities, the people, and of course the firemen.
    Have personally been driving and selling and fooling around with fire apparatus for near 50 years, I also have many million miles on me in Kenworth trucks and all kinds of fire apparatus running 49 states, and nine canadian provinces and territories, as an internationally regarded and respected fire apparatus expert if I can say so myself, your out of line telling me I said something stupid. Leo Stapleton started this aluminum thing in Boston 25 years or so ago. About 25 years ago the FDNY finally started buying Seagraves with tandem rear ax. 400 or more Seagraves in FDNY right now all have Telma retarders. Send me your private email, Ill forward photos of P company and E1 cabs, some held together with double stick tape.
  • DaGonz
    I am not out of line.You did say something stupid and callous.
    You on the other hand, by posting this...

    "Have personally been driving and selling and fooling around with fire apparatus for near 50 years, I also have many million miles on me in Kenworth trucks and all kinds of fire apparatus running 49 states, and nine canadian provinces and territories, as an internationally regarded and respected fire apparatus expert if I can say so myself"


    You come across as a self aggrandizing pompous ass. Newsflash.... Seagraves suffer crash damages... so do Macks, Ferraras, Pierces, E- Ones, Rosenbauers, Central States,
    Kenworths, Peterbilts, Navistars, Volvo-White, Fords, GMCs, Dennis, MAN, Magirius Deutz and any other fire apparatus or cab and chassis manufacturer.

    I have no intentions of sending you my private email.. nor do I want yours.








  • Mark
    This is a totally sad situation, the City of Boston should bear all the blame. Poor maintenance and poorly trained mechanics caused the death of a very fine individual. I have driven a rig or two with air brakes and I always thought the brakes locked up with no air pressure in them. Am I wrong?
  • firegeezer
    Every truck that I have driven, not just firetrucks, but regular trucks and buses, had an emergency brake that was supplied by a separate, reserve air tank.  If the regular brakes lost all air, the emergency brake would come on automatically and bring everything to a stop.
    But you know, with fire engines everything on it has to be specified on the order.  Leads to a couple of questions:  Did BFD fail to spec the emergency brakes?  Does Massachusetts not REQUIRE them on all trucks in the state? 
    I'm pretty sure that they are legally mandated in my state.

    Inquiring minds want to know.




    ________________________________
  • Mark
    Bill

    I have thought from the start there were many questions unanswered and now it is even more of a cover up. The tail is wagging the dog and no one can stop it. No one wants to take responsibility for the city's inability to maintain their fleet. Would that happen here where we work and live?
blog comments powered by Disqus