Skip to content


Lt. Pagano Murder Trial Update

Comments Off

THE JURY DELIBERATING THE FATE OF NICHOLAS GIANQUITTI, accused of murdering Cranston Fire Lieutenant James Pagano, recessed yesterday at 4:30 pm. 

Following the closing arguments by both sides earlier in the day, the judge instructed the jury.  Providence Journal reporter Maria Armental, who has been live-blogging from the courtroom, reported:

Superior Court Judge Robert D. Krause instructed the jury to consider acquittal, first-degree and second-degree murder, and voluntary and involuntary manslaughter in judging Gianquitti.

Krause also instructed the jury on the legal definition of intent — needed to prove murder — and self-defense — which Gianquitti has invoked in his defense.

The Superior Court judge told jurors they are only to consider the second charge — discharging a firearm during the commission of a violent crime — if they find Gianquitti guilty of either murder or manslaughter.

In judging the case, Krause instructed the jury to consider the evidence presented — both testimony and other proof presented at trial and circumstancial evidence — and make “reasonable inferences” based on their life experiences.

The jury will resume their deliberations this morning.

WPRI Ch. 12 has this morning’s update:

Firegeezer report on the crime in May, 2008, HERE, HERE and HERE.
Reports on the trial are HERE and HERE.